Well...I am a newly minted English teacher here in southern California. My students read whatever they want to...but they must read SOMETHING during the first 15 minutes of class. We don't really have enough "free reading" books, fiction OR non-fiction, so I have amassed a good sized supply of books ranging from Stephen King all the way to biographies of historical figures.
The students seem to love it, and I haven't had a problem yet. I guess only time will tell....
Then again, I also force my students to think for themselves, which is really difficult for my 10th grade HONORS students!!